[ Disclaimer, --- , ]
This page is intended for a more technical discussion of the game mechanics. For instance, equations governing combat, how STA translates into HP, how the con color system scales with level. It is important that this information applies to p1999 mechanics, as opposed to Live mechanics, post-Velious mechanics, or EQEmu mechanics. Each topic can have a list of reference links which may or may not apply. There should be consensus that the information is valid for p1999 before it is copied into this page.
Miscellaneous Details for p1999
These are verified to be true on Project 1999. These are largely changes that were announced during patches.
- If a mob is moving (not including a result of fear or flee) when the damage from a dot is applied, it will take 66% of the damage that it would have normally taken.
- All classes that can exceed 200 Bind Wound can bind to 70%.
- Can only assassinate humanoid targets.
- Monk AC weight penalty starts at 14 and scales up at certain levels. More details here
- The /target command can target mobs, players, or corpses as long as they are "within range."
- Bash damage absorbed by a rune can still stun you.
- PvP Attacks do not require the attacker to be facing their target.
- Rogue hide will function the same as invis + IVU stacked, while providing protection from nearly the entirety of mobs that would otherwise see through magical invisibility.
- Non-rogue (racial hide) will only function the same as magical invisibility.
- Mobs that see through invis/IVU will similarly see through racial hide, but not rogue hide except in extremely rare cases, including but not limited to Fire Giants in SolB and Chokidai in Chardok.
- One 24 hour period of game time lasts 72 minutes in real time = 1 ingame hour is exactly 3 minutes in real time.
- Night time starts and ends at certain hours and varies from zone to zone. The most common night time cycle is 9pm - 7am.
- Level 56+ NPCs are immune to stuns.
- NPCs level 50 and above can be taunted. (Blue only)
- Blinded mobs will attack anything in melee range before fleeing.
- NPCs have the potential to gate starting at 20% of their health.
- NPC's will regain 25% HP after gating.
- NPC perma procs can't proc unless damage is done to the player.
- Vox and Nagafen will banish players over level 52.
- Mob AE's hitting a Feign Death player does break FD and will add player to aggro list. (March 2013 Patch)
- Mobs do not immediately aggro players within 3 seconds of spawning, and they are immune to any non-targetted spells (PB AEs or targeted AEs they aren't the target of) in that time.
- Any spells cast by NPCs on PCs will break FD, regardless of resist. Except dispells.
- Being perceived as invisible (whether that be from invis/sneak/hide) when standing from FD does not remove you from NPC feign memory.
- Added the distinction between direct and indirect hate: Mobs with indirect hate (obtained by another mob yelling for help) on a target cannot yell for help to transfer hate for their target to another NPC. The only way to prevent the transfer of direct hate to another nearby NPC is to be sneaking in the proper area of that NPC's visibility. Invis/IVU/Hide etc. no longer have any impact on whether direct aggro will be transferred.
- Some mobs now have the ability to scan the surrounding area for new targets while already engaged.
- Most high end raid targets will announce to nearby players which player was first to engage. This should help when multiple guilds attempt to engage simultaneously.
- (all) npcs can innately proc on attacks. This isn't limited to kick and bash. Theoretically, they can proc innates on contact hits.
- NPCs who cannot see you will not respond to /say.
- Completing quests with an NPC who is charmed will no longer trigger faction changes associated with that quest/npc.
- Aggro checks on mobs that are engaged will not ignore players who are sitting. Sitting will add you to their hate list.
- Detrimental AE spells have an upper limit of 25 targets, as per a special change in the September 5th, 2016 patch, to limit large AEs contrary to classic so as to prevent certain game exploitations on p99. Full details are in the patch thread: Patch Notes 9/5/2016
- Druid charm CHA equivalence identical to necromancers (further details?).
- Lifetaps will only resist when outside the level limit (which is? 6 levels?).
- Regular runes absorb spell damage.
- All buffs go into the main buff window, including bard songs, which count towards 15 buff limit.
- Level 51+ buffs have a limited level range for the target they're being casted on.
- The Lull line of spells do not notify the caster when they have worn off.
- Giants/Dragons may no longer be stunned or mesmerized.
- Crippling blows have a chance to stun.
- Rogues can get critical hits, deadly strikes, and assassinates on throwing attacks.
- The player attack delay floor is 5 delay.
- Archery has no damage bonuses.
- Offhand double attack can only succeed if double attack skill >= 150.
- Weapon damage cap for sub-30 players (added 2/20/12).
- All Hand to Hand weapons are now 1H Blunt weapons (changed 2/20/12).
- "Classic pet experience distribution." In a group, a pet does not take a portion of the experience. When soloing, if the pet does more than 50% of the damage on a mob, it takes half the experience for the kill.
- NPCs/pets can equip items in all slots.
- NPCs/pets can swap weapons if the new weapon has a lesser delay.
- Pet damage increases if given a weapon with damage higher than their innate damage.
- Warrior NPCs/pets bash more frequently than kick.
- No out of combat regen bonus for pets. (this does not apply to sit regen bonus)
- Higher level Magician, Necromancer, and Shadowknight pets will automatically dual wield. Otherwise, pets only DW if given two weapons. (Blue only)
PvP Details for p1999
Strikethrough = Seems to no longer be true (dumb change, but no longer true)
These changes were made with red99 in mind, although some may apply to general PvP combat on p99 as well.
- Archery will not work over water
- PvP Spell Damage was reduced from 80% to 66%.
10% chance for direct damage spells to land for full until the chance to resist the spell is <=10%
5% chance to land any spell
- No heart beat ticks with Root in PvP.
- No Partials from Root and Snare (such as snared for 2 seconds, then break)
- Resist rates on Root and Snares are increased in PvP.
- There is a chance to break root from melee. The chance for root to break is equal to 20% of the damage dealt.
- Players can water dance / hop to avoid getting hit by detrimental spells in PvP.
- OOR dispelling is disabled.
- Lifetap over time spells properly display on the target's buff bar.
- Mitigation disciplines reduce both incoming PvE and PvP damage.
- Mesmerization spells bypass the level checks when used in PvP. Note: Players will not be mesmerized by their own AoEs if they are above the level cap (temporary note, due to technical aspects).
- Damage shields do full damage in PvP.
- Level 50+ rangers will get the same bonus against non-moving, non-rooted players as they do against NPCs.
- A maximum stun duration exists. The values on this are still being tuned.
- Pet cast spells have the same resist modifications as player cast spells.
- Pets, when charmed, will be instantly poofed.
- Rogue blinds last a quarter of their PvE duration, but will have their partials skewed higher.
- The maximum resist chance has been set to 98%, up from 95%.
- Linkdead players who are engaged in PvP combat will not poof after 30 seconds.
- A number of spells are unresistible, such as Rapture, the Winged Death line, the Lifetap line, and Splurt, although Winged Death line of spells, as well as Breath of Ro fire-based DoTs, are currently bugged and SHOULD have a -10 and -100 resist check, respectively.
- Root spells have linear resist functions, and are broken into 3 tiers with 98% resist caps at 60mr, 90mr, and 125mr.
Exclusive to Red99:
- EXP Bonus scaling added 2/20/12. The Bonus will scale from 100% at Level 1 to 0% at Level 50. (100 - (Level * 2)).
- Merchants separate items with different charges in their list.
- Changed PvP Spell damage from 80 -> 67%. This is reverting a previous change. (spells only)
- Added a 5% per attack reduction in channeling chance.
- Capped tradeskills at 200.
- Spells with a dispel component are resistible on PvP servers (Highsun, Lava Breath, Frost Breath, etc). Pure dispels (Cancel Magic, Taper Enchantment, Alenia's) continue to be unresistible.
- Using an instaclick item will remove any remaining GCD.
- Environmental death on PvP server will now result in no mana after death.
- Set spell debuff bonus to 50%.
- Reduced resist caps of CC spell lines.
- Made poison and disease spells easier to resist.
- Lowered pvp resist base for Malise, Malisement, Malosi, Malosini, Malosinia. This should make them easier to resist.
Minions gather, their forms appearing as time and space coalesce...
A simulated server restart, simulated respawn, or EarthQuake causes all mobs, including raid targets, to respawn. It is manually triggered by a staff member such as Rogean or Nilbog.
"Earthquakes" are designed to simulate the classic experience of EverQuest servers being taken down temporarily for maintenance, which resulted in fresh mobs when the server came online.
- As of 11/18/18:
- 0-3 Simulated Respawns will occur each month; 1-3 being the normal amount,
- and 0 existing as a possibility if Rogean or Nilbog cannot do them at all.
- See Corpse
Once you surpass your character's weight limit, you will become encumbered.
- This will cause a loss of movement speed and agility, which, in turn, causes a loss of AC.
- Your weight limit is determined by the amount of strength your character has.
- Monks are subject to much lower weight limits than all other classes.
- They will face an AC penalty for exceeding a weight of 14.9 before level 15, 15.9 for levels 15-29, 16.9 for levels 30-44, 17.9 for levels 45-50, 18.9 for levels 51-54, 20.9 for levels 55-59, and 24.9 at level 60.
Faction System and Levels
- Main article: Faction
- http://www.therunes.net/faction.htm (live ~2002)
- http://web.archive.org/web/20020618052012/http://forums.castersrealm.com/cgi-bin/eq/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=9&t=004566 (live, May 2001)
Note: The numerical values for changing between different con levels has always been debated (e.g. scowling is -1000 or below). These values on p1999 are likely the same as for stock EQEmu but this is unconfirmed. The following information is based off early experiments and direct data from live. Similar to experience numbers, in the very early days of live the direct faction numbers were sent to the client.
Note: The amount of numerical faction raised/lowered for killing any specific mob or completing any specific quest is unknown on p1999. Many of these values are likely similar to stock EQEmu, but significant adjustments have certainly been made.
1. Faction in Everquest
The faction system is the relation ship between YOU, the player character, and the AI controlled creatures of Norrath.
The word faction has two common meanings:
- Faction: noun. An associated group of NPCs, Identified by thier faction number and a faction description. An example of this would 'Faction 232', or 'ClawsofVeeshan'.
- Faction: noun. The relative relationship between you and any given creature as given by the /con command in game. An example of this would be 'Lord Nagafen scowls at you, ready to attack'.
For the sake of clarity, I will use CONSIDER whenever I mean faction(2) and FACTION whenever I mean faction(1) in this document.
Important things to realize about faction:
- Each AI controlled creature belongs to one and only one faction.
- The consider changes that occur when you kill a creature or do a quest have NOTHING to do with the faction of the creature killed or the quest giver. While often they are often similar, that similarity is simply a statement of consistency in Verant's world.
2. How Consider Works
When you /con a creature, the Everquest server generates a number that is your relative ranking of like and dislike from that creature's faction. This number is composed of:
- A modifier for your god
- A modifier for your race
- A modifier for your class
- A modifier for your own faction changing efforts
- A modifier that is spell based
- A modifier that is NPC specific
- A zone modifier
The sum of these modifiers is your consider number. What is output by the client is one of nine messages, depending on the consider number (unconfirmed numbers on p99):
- Below -801, scowls at you, ready to attack
- -800 to -701, glares at you threateningly
- -700 to -501, glowers at you dubiously
- -500 to -101, is apprehensive
- -100 to 99, is indifferent
- 100 to 499, is amiable
- 500 to 699, kindly considers you
- 700 to 1099, looks upon you warmly
- 1100 and up, regards you as an ally
All player characters on blue servers have a base consider of 0.
Consider USED to be capped at +2000 and -2000. It was changed at some point to handle larger values. There MAY still be specific caps associated with certain factions, but I have not found any current evidence that this is true.
How do the modifers work?
- The GOD modifer is fixed for each faction. Worshipers of each god have fixed plus or minus consider for each faction.
- The RACE modifier is fixed for each faction. Each race has a fixed plus or minus consider for each faction.
- The CLASS is fixed for each faction. Each CLASS has a fixed plus or minus for each faction.
- The PERSONAL modifier is set at your character creation for each faction, and is changed as a result of your in-game actions. For example, if I do the Kerran Key quest in qeynos I get about +30 to my personal Steel Warrior consider.
- The SPELL based modifier raises the consider number a set amount per spell. For example, Collaboration adds 300. Note: Some equipped items have worn spell effects that modify faction.
- The NPC modifer overrides other considerations. For example, Gypsies have a set faction based on RACE and CLASS, and GOD that cannot be changed by spells.
- The ZONE modifier is a set amount that is added to certain personal consider values upon entering a zone. In almost all cases, the ZM is zero. This information on ZM is based on two bits of sketchy information. First, a vague statement from Verant that a consider ZM causes the 'You swipe at a %t. A %t dies' messages that appear when you zone. Second, one example, that of the Kromrif, who are on the same faction, yet con exactly 100 different for me in two different zones.
Here are a few examples:
I have a personal modifer of 2697 with WolvesoftheNorth. Since I am a dark elf, I lose 200, since I worship Innoruuk I lose 300, but since I am an enchanter I gain 100. My total faction is 2697-200-300+100, or 2297, making me an ally.
Troll Shadowknights who worship Cazic Thule that have maximum positive faction with Frogloks of Guk are still glowered at dubiously by frogloks
3. The effect of Spells on Consider
- (a) Invisible, camoflauge, sneak, hide, and invisible to undead set your consider to 0 for NPCs who don't see through them.
- (b) The faction-changing enchanter spells have these effects:
- Alliance: +100 consider
- Benevolence: +200 consider
- Collaboration: +300 consider
Only one instance of these spells can be alive at any time, and all three spells overwrite each other.
- (c) Illusions affect your faction as if you actually changed to the race of the illusion. Not all NPCs have the same faction towards a given race, so take care. Here is an example of two barbarian NPCS with different faction in the same zone:
|Me||Maula FishCatcher||Maula's fisherman buddy|
(4) Where do consider changes come from?
- (a) Killing creatures. Usually killing a creature produces one or more +considers and one or more -considers. The amount gotten from killing varies, and I have seen values from +1 to +250 and -1 to -200. Typical kill values are +/- 1 to 5.
- (b) Doing quests. Each quest step usually changes consider values for several factions. Typical numbers are +/-1 and +/-5. A few quests produce consider changes in the +/- hundreds.
- (c) Specials. Some special game items and actions (like hailing Tazgar the Efreeti in The Temple of Solusek Ro) can change consider. I don't have any large list of these, and would be happy to learn about them.
(5) Various topics
- (a) Monsters who do not see you because you are behind them, etc, simply don't see you. Your consider remains the same.
- (b) Charisma has no effect on consider.
- (c) Factions cross continents, zone, etc. RingofScale in Permafrost is the same as RingOfScale in Kunark.
- (d) Factions are not interrelated. Losing consider with ServantsofMistmoore does not change my MayongMistmoore consider.
Consider Color Scalings with Level
- See Consider
|Level 60 STA to HP Conversions|
|WAR||1 STA = 6 HP|
|SHD / PAL||1 STA = 5.2 HP|
|RNG||1 STA = 4.2 HP|
|BRD / MNK / ROG||1 STA = 4 HP|
|CLR / DRU / SHM||1 STA = 3 HP|
|ENC / MAG / NEC / WIZ||1 STA = 2.4 HP|
|NOTE: Conversions scale up with level, this chart only shows level 60.|
|Level 50 STA to HP Conversions|
|WAR||1 STA = 4.5 HP|
|SHD / PAL||1 STA = 3.8 HP|
|RNG||1 STA = 3.3 HP|
|BRD / MNK / ROG||1 STA = 3.0 HP|
|CLR / DRU / SHM||1 STA = 2.5 HP|
|ENC / MAG / NEC / WIZ||1 STA = 2.0 HP|
|NOTE: Conversions scale up with level, this chart only shows level 50.|
Weapon Proc Rates
- http://everquest.allakhazam.com/wiki/eq:Proc (~Live, sounds right)
Proc rates are computed on a procs per minute basis. I believe this is the same number for the vast majority of weapons, but some weapons have a higher adjusted procs per minute rate, and some such (with big procs) are adjusted downwards. The game translates the weapons targeted procs per minute and applies it to your weapon. If you are swinging 100 times a minute with your main hand, and the targeted procs per minute is 5, then the game essentially makes this computation:
- 5 procs divided by 100 swings = chance to proc per swing
- 5 / 100 = 0.05 or 1 in twenty chance.
Now if your haste wears off, and you're only swinging 50 times per minute, the game actually will up your chance to proc per swing
- 5 / 50 = 0.10 or 1 in 10 chance to proc per swing
This is confusing to some people but it's definitely true.
The rough formula is (DEX/170) + 0.5 = proc per minute rate for main hand, and offhand is half that rate.
Melee Combat and Damage
- See also: Statistics#Damage Per Second (DPS)
Note: Melee damage (specifically, damage bonuses) are undergoing a revamp with the launch of Kunark.
- http://forums.station.sony.com/eq/posts/list.m?topic_id=161556 (Live)
- http://web.archive.org/web/20010613230142/www.mysticalorder.com/avgslash.shtml (Live ~2001)
- http://www.project1999.com/forums/showthread.php?t=79696 (Rogean posted 2H Dmg Bonus Code)
Weapon Damage / Efficiency
Weapon damage can be figured by using this formula:
Weapon autoattack will (ignoring other factors like str) hit for up to (dmg * 2) where dmg is the weapon's stated damage, but this value is subject to a level based cap. Originally all classes were subject to the same limits:
(This has been incorrect for years, the cap is NOT a total damage cap. It is the base weapon damage that is caped, with low strength you will hit double base weapon damage, with more you hit over. If you have a 20 damage 30 delay weapon at level 1. It will be changed to 10 damage 30 delay by the game when calculating damage. This is why a level 1 Ogre can break the incorrectly understood cap.)
- levels 1-9 - damage cap is base weapon damage of 10
- levels 10-19 - damage cap is base weapon damage of 14
- Levels 20-29 - damage cap is base weapon damage of 30
- 30+ - lifted, can do 2x weapon damage or more based on class
The patch on Monday, February 13th, 2017 introduced per-class limits:
- levels 1-9 - damage cap is 12
- levels 10-19 - damage cap is 20
- Levels 20-29 - damage cap is 24
- Levels 30-39 - damage cap is 36
- Level 40+ - damage cap is 40
- levels 1-9 - damage cap is 18
- levels 10-19 - damage cap is 24
- Levels 20-29 - damage cap is 40
- Levels 30-39 - damage cap is 52
- Level 40+ - damage cap is 80
melee & tank
- levels 1-9 - damage cap is 20
- levels 10-19 - damage cap is 28
- Levels 20-29 - damage cap is 60
- Levels 30-39 - damage cap is 120
- Level 40+ - damage cap is 200
The dmg*2 formula for autoattack is true until lvl 28 where you get 1 bonus damage every 3 levels to your main hand attack. So at level 50 you get 8 extra bonus damage:
- main hand = (dmg*2)+8
- off hand = dmg*2
That's why a fast weapon can perform as good as a slower weapon with better ratio. For example, a dragon spined claw (10/21) only outdamages a revultant whip (5/14) by about 10% or maybe a bit more (that's my personal parse). For off hand, you need the best possible ratio (no damage bonus).
Role of STR
As for str, you will notice more effects at later level. It does increase my max damage when I go from 180 (unbuffed) to about 250 (shaman buff). In the end, my main hand 10/21 has a max damage of about 45, so from the formula:
- (2*10)+8 = 28
I have an extra 17 damage, I would think that it is all coming from str bonus at my level? Not sure.
The other effect of str is that it raises your ATK (about 1 ATK for 1 str) and the more ATK you have, the more likely you will get high hits.
Role of STR on other emulated servers
The source code for EQ Emulator calculates max damage based on Weapon Damage, STR, Weapon Skill, Class, and Player Level. This algorithm may have been changed on P99, but here it is for reference:
- [Max Damage] = ([Mod] x [Weapon Damage]) + [Main Hand Bonus] (rounded down)
- [Weapon Damage] is the damage listed on the weapon.
- [Main hand bonus] is always 0 for non-melee characters, and weapons wielded in the off-hand.
- [Main hand bonus] for one handed weapons is: ([Player Level] - 25) / 3 (rounded down)
- [Mod] is calculated as: ([Weapon Skill] + [STR] -75) / 100
- If [Mod] is less than 2, then 2 is used instead.
- If [Player Level] is less than 10, then [Max Damage] is capped at 20.
- If [Player Level] is less than 20, then [Max Damage] is capped at 40.
So at low levels, [Max Damage] is always twice the listed weapon damage. In the example above, a level 50 melee character using a 10 damage weapon, with 200 weapon skill and 250 strength, max damage would be calculated as:
- [Mod] = (200 + 250 - 75) / 100 = 3.75
- [Main Hand Bonus] = (50 - 25) / 3 = 8
- [Max Damage] = (3.75 x 10) + 8 = 45
Note that increased damage from strength is applied to both main hand and off hand weapons, and is a multiplier. The level based [Main Hand Bonus] is a flat number that is only added to the main hand weapon and is not affected by strength.
NOTE: This formula is not the one used in P99 because, using it, I found my theoretical max damage with a Blam Stick and 255 STR to be 134 but have screenshot evidence of myself doing more than this.
- [Main hand bonus] for two handed weapons is a higher value than for 1H that is also based on the weapon delay. See http://lucy.allakhazam.com/dmgbonus.html
Note that the above (live) table is likely incorrect for p1999. The 2H damage bonus was made "classic" (unknown details, ref).
Dual Wield / Double Attack Chance
The value of "MaxSkill" may be ~400 (unconfirmed). That would mean at 200 double attack skill half of your hits would trigger a double attack.
For triple attacks, the same check is done using half your double attack skill level.
For a monk, your chance to dual wield is based off this formula: (your level + your dual wield skill) / 400. So at level 60 with 252 dual wield, you'd have a 78% chance to dual wield. For other classes the formula may be slightly different (e.g. / 500 instead of / 400).
Backstab Damage Calculations
At level 51, your offense skill is 215, and your backstab skill is 203.
Backstab uses a weapon damage multiplier of: 2 + (Skill * 0.02).
((215 + 200 + (55 / 5)) * 13 * (2 + (203 * 0.02))) / 100 = 335.6028
If you had, for example, 200 strength:
((215 + 200) * 13 * (2 + (203 * 0.02))) / 100 = 326.93700
Under 200 starts to hurt even more since over 200 has diminishing returns. 150:
((215 + 150) * 13 * (2 + (203 * 0.02))) / 100 = 287.54700
At level 60, your offense skill will be 252, and backstab will be 225. With a 13 damage weapon at max strength:
((252 + 200 + (55 / 5)) * 13 * (2 + (225 * 0.02))) / 100 = 391.23500
With Ragebringer or any other 15 damage weapon:
((252 + 200 + (55 / 5)) * 15 * (2 + (225 * 0.02))) / 100 = 451.42500
Descriptive Statistics and the EQ Magic System
- See also: Statistics#Secondary Stats
My Purpose (by Nenelar Valandur, High Elf Elementalist, E’ci, Nov 2000 (ref)): I’ve read many comparisons of spells on many website and many online forums. Almost exclusively the power of spells is compared based on the maximum damage they can deliver and the efficiency of mana put into those spells is compared by the ratio: Point of damage per point of mana.
These are valid measures for comparison. However, they tell a very limited story in terms of the true power and efficiency of the classes. My purpose is to offer a more complete view of casting power using different statistics than what I’ve seen proposed previously. But first let me start with what seems to be a reasonable argument using the old statistics:
What We Think We Know
- The level 60 wizard spell “Sunstrike” costs 450 and does 1615 maximum damage. That’s a ratio of 450:1615 or 1:3.59.
- The level 60 magician spell “Seeking Flame of Seukor” costs 350 mana and does 1024 maximum damage. That’s a ratio of 350:1024 or 1:3.2.
At level 60, the wizard is roughly 10% more mana efficient than the magician and does roughly 60% more damage.
Note: Many of you don’t care about the numbers. It’s OK to prefer to play the game without knowing the numbers behind it. You don’t have to read further than this. Go play…have fun! I find this type of research into the game fun. That’s why I do it. I also like to know as much as I can about my class. If you’re like me, read on. If not, I cannot be held responsible for the increased awareness you may obtain by reading further! This isn’t a rant about anything!
Quick Reference Glossary:
Some basic knowledge of terminology is assumed below. You’ll need to understand the following concepts:
- Tick - the basic unit of time in EQ equal to 6 seconds of real time.
- Casting time - the time it takes to channel mana into the spell. This is represented by the purple channeling bar that appears when you click a spell.
- Recovery time - the time it takes you as a caster to “recover” from the task of channeling. This is represented by the grayed out spell gems after casting.
- Recast time - certain spells have an additional time to “reset.” Only that spell gem will remain grayed out, after all others have become available.
- DD - Direct Damage. A spell that does all its damage in a single blast is called a DD spell.
- DOT - Damage Over Time. A spell that does a certain amount of damage every tick throughout its duration is called a DOT spell.
The Descriptive Statistics
Mana to Damage Multiplier (MDM)
The power of a class to convert mana into damage is different for each spell and generally increases with player level. MDM is the multiplier (a constant) that solves the equation: ManaCost * MDM = MaximumSpellDamage for a given spell. Or, restated: MDM = MaximumSpellDamage / ManaCost. Low level spells usually have a MDM of less than 1 since they cost more mana than they do in damage, whereas high level spells are always above 1. This is not really different than the ratio expressed the old way. Its value will not become apparent until a later analysis is published.
- Seeking Flame of Seukor (Magician, 59) has a mana cost of 320 and does 1024 max damage. MDM is therefore 1024 damage / 320 mana = 3.2
- Sunstrike (Wizard, 60) has a mana cost of 450 and does 1615 max damage. MDM is therefore 1615 damage / 450 mana = 3.59
In this example, the Wizard spell is indeed roughly 10% more mana efficient than the Magician spell.
Damage Per Tick (DPT)
The power of a class to deliver damage within a given period of time also changes as players grow in experience. This measure is important as it scales the speed with which a caster can deliver damage. Most DD spells have a recovery time of 2.5 seconds (time before any spell may be cast) and some spells have a recast waiting period. By adding the time to cast the spell and the greater of the time to recover or time to recast, a total time invested for a spell can be obtained. This number should be used for comparison’s sake only since DD spells do not actually deliver damage per tick. This statistic will be used later to compare spells, for now I simply describe it here. Its value will not become apparent until a later analysis is published.
- Seeking Flame of Seukor (Magician, 59) has a casting time of 7 seconds and a recover of 2.5 seconds. Total time invested in casting this spell is therefore 9.5 seconds. The spell does 1024 max damage in a single instant of time during that 9.5 seconds. (7 seconds of channeling, bang! 1024 damage, 2.5 seconds of recovery) 9.5 seconds is 1.58 ticks. 1024 damage / 1.58 ticks = 647 damage per tick.
- Sunstrike (Wizard, 60) has a casting time of 7 seconds and a recover of 2.5 seconds. Total time invested in casting this spell is therefore also 9.5 seconds. 1615 damage / 1.58 ticks = 1020 damage per tick
In this example, the Wizard spell delivers 57.6% more damage per tick than the Magician (while both have mana to cast).
Full Mana Damage (FMD)
The power of a casting class to deliver damage is further defined by the total mana available to that caster. All things being equal, more mana means more damage. While DPT measures the speed with which damage is delivered, FMD seeks to quantify the total damage a caster could do with a full bar of mana. For any given spell, this calculation is: FMD = (TotalManaAvailable / SpellManaCost) * SpellMaxDamage.
The first part of this calculation requires that the quantity of mana when full be known. This is unfortunately, one of the mysteries of EQ. I am using the approximate formula: ((Intelligence / 5) + 2) * LevelofCaster to estimate the mana available to a caster. While this formula is likely not the exact formula used in the game, it is a close approximate. Further, since this analysis uses the same formula for all classes compared, it does not bias any class. (Note: The druid is a priest class and uses Wisdom instead of Intelligence for mana, but the formula is the same). For the purposes of this analysis, a constant number of 200 for Intelligence or Wisdom is used. Therefore, total mana available is: (200/5) + 2 * Level = 42 * Level.
- A level 1 caster would have 42 mana. A level 60 caster would have 60 * 42 = 2520 mana.
- If the level 60 wizard were to cast Sunstrike (mana cost 450, 1615 damage), the calculation would be: FMD = (2520 / 450) * 1615 = 9044.
- If a level 60 magician were to cast Seeking Flame of Seukor (mana cost 320, 1024 damage), the calculation would be: FMD = (2520 / 320) * 1024 = 7930.
In this example, the Wizard does 1,114 more damage with full mana than the Magician at level 60 (when both have equal mana available to cast).
Full Mana Ticks (FMT)
In the above example, the total damage capacity with full mana was calculated. However, the ability of a casting class to deliver this damage is dependent on the time each spell cast requires. The sum of all the casting time required to “chain cast” a full bar of mana can be expressed in ticks to compare the time efficiency of casting classes. The formula looks like this: FMT = (TotalManaAvailable / SpellManaCost) * SpellTimeInvestment. Recall from the DPT example, that there are three components to consider in SpellTimeInvestment: Casting time, recovery time and recast time. Most spells have only a recovery time. For such spells, casting time and recovery time can be added together to calculate the total time invested in a single cast of that spell. However, if a spell has a recast time greater than the recovery time, that time is added to casting time instead of the recovery time.
- The spell Suntrike requires 7 seconds to channel and 2.5 seconds of recovery. The time to burn a full bar of mana on this spell at level 60 is therefore: (2520 / 450) * 9.5 = 53 seconds = 8.83 ticks.
- The spell Seeking Flame of Seukor also requires 7 seconds to channel and 2.5 seconds of recovery. The time to burn a full bar of mana on this spell at level 60 is therefore: (2520 / 350) * 9.5 = 74 = 12.33 ticks.
In this example, the wizard not only does more damage, the wizard does it 3.5 ticks (21 seconds faster)!
What We Thought We Knew:
- At level 60, the wizard is roughly 10% more mana efficient and does roughly 60% more damage than a level 60 magician.
What We Now Know:
- At level 60, a wizard is roughly 10% more mana efficient, 39% more time efficient, delivers about 14% more damage per bar of mana, and delivers 57% more damage in the same amount of time as a level 60 magician.
Note: We haven’t accounted for the magician’s pet, the wizard’s pet, or the wizard’s inherently lower resists. Those will all be discussed later.
The current statistics used to describe and compare spells tell only a partial story. Like most partial truths, these statistics lead us to make seemingly logical conclusions that are in fact incomplete at best, or at worst totally false. The new statistics above make enable better comparisons within the magic system of EQ.
Vendor Pricing, Charisma, and Faction